Obituaries (July 7)

Elizabeth Brennan Collins

Bainbridge News, September 12, 1940

People of the community were greatly shocked to hear of the sudden death of Elizabeth Brennan Collins, 68, wife of Thomas Collins and a well known resident of Bainbridge [Chenango Co., NY], which occurred Friday evening, September 6, 1940 at her home, after she had been partially incapacitated for several years.  Mrs. Collins, who came to the village as a bride in 1892, was a devoted wife and mother, and her many friends will always remember her endless generosity and abundant kindness as testified by the beautiful floral tributes and other gifts which were amply expressive. Though she suffered in the last years of her life, she pursued life with courage and undiminished good nature and optimism.  She was a member of St. John's Church and the rosary Society.  Also, was one of the first members of the Bainbridge Women's Club, was a charter member of Slater-Silvernail Post of the America Legion Auxiliary, and had three sons overseas.  Born May 6, 1872, at Abby-Leix, Ireland, she was the daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Patrick Brennan. She later moved to Dublin where she remained until coming to America in 1891.  In January, 1892, she was united in marriage to Thomas Collins. The deceased is survived by her husband; two daughters, Mrs. S.R. Bennett, of Bainbridge, and Mrs. George Willits, of Burmingham, Mich.; four sons, Thomas Collins, Jr., of Westfield, Mass., Edwin I. Collins, of Utica, Algwynne Collins, of Shelter Island Heights, L.I., Edson W. Collins, of Norwich; one brother, Joseph Brennan, of Endicott; several grandchildren, nephews, and one niece, Miss Mary Brennan, of New York City. The funeral was held Monday morning at 10 o'clock in St. John's Church, where a Requiem Mass. was celebrated by the Rev. Francis Zimmer. The pall-bearers were:  Dr. Edward Danforth, S.R. Bennett, Sebert Hollenbeck, Hugh Collins, Dr. J.M. Flannery and Lewis Higler.  Interment was in St. Peter's Cemetery [Bainbridge].

Mary Eugenia (Campbell) Bristol

Bainbridge News, November 19, 1942

The funeral of Mary Eugenia Bristol was held on Monday, Nov. 16 at the Colwell Bros. Funeral Parlors with the Rev. Steele, pastor of the Sidney Episcopal Church, officiating.  Interment was in the Episcopal Cemetery [Bainbridge, Chenango Co., NY].  Mrs. Bristol, a life long Bainbridge resident, was born on the East side on July 21, 1863, the daughter of Burr C. Campbell and Mary E. Pettys Campbell and spent her childhood on the East Side, Bainbridge.  On April 29, 1883, she was united in marriage to Joseph E. Bristol of Bainbridge and they made their home here.  On Saturday, Nov. 7, Mrs. Bristol suffered a broken shoulder and she developed pneumonia, death coming on Friday, Nov. 13.  Surviving are a son, Daniel Bristol, of Bainbridge, a daughter, Mrs. Charles Greene, also of Bainbridge; four grandchildren and two great grandchildren.  Pall-bearers were all members of the family and were:  Lee and Ansel Sargent, of Gilbertsville; Ward Loomis, Charles Pettys, Chester Bame and Charles Greene.  Mrs. Bristol, a member of the local Episcopal Church, had many friends who deeply mourn her passing.  

Mime A. (Ferguson) Norton

Bainbridge news, October 8, 1942

Mrs. Mime A. Norton passed away Saturday, Sept. 26, at the home of her daughter, Mrs. George Foster.  Mrs. Norton had been in failing health for the past year. Born march 14, 1861, on Searles Hill in the Town of Guilford [Chenango Co., NY], she was the daughter of Chauncey and Eunice Newotn Ferguson.  On Nov. 27, 1881, she was united in marriage to Britton Norton, who died on June 4, 1920.  Of this union seven children were born four of whom survive, Mrs. Anna Riley, Mrs. George Foster, Mrs. John Parsons, of Bainbridge, and Chauncey Norton, of Elmira; also a sister, Mrs. R.L. Banner, of Bainbridge; 16 grandchildren, 31 great grandchildren and several nieces and nephews.  Mrs. Norton was a member of the Baptist Church and attended as long as her health would permit.  She was held in high esteem and loved by all who knew her as one always patient and thoughtful of others. The funeral service was held at the home of Mr. and Mrs. John Parsons, Tuesday, the Rev. R. Lewis Johnson officiating. The bearers were Egbert and Kenneth Riley, William Foster, Howard Bliss, George Myers and Harry Smith. Burial was in the family plot in the Bennettsville Cemetery [Chenango Co., NY].

George Burton

Bainbridge News, October 15, 1942 

The light of last Thursday morning brought more bad news to the village when it was earned by stunned residents that George Burton, one of the most popular and best liked men of the community, had succumbed to a final attack of asthma the previous night.  It was hard for his countless friends to realize that the man they had always admired for his pleasant manner, friendly ways and cheerful disposition had left their midst.  Born Feb. 6, 1889, in nearby Afton [Chenango Co., NY], George was the son of Richard and Josephine Taft Burton and spent most of his life in this section of the country.  On July 4, 1910, he was married to Gertrude Gordon at Cooks Falls and they spent the first year of their married life in Middletown, where he served his apprenticeship and learned his trade.  Coming to Bainbridge in April of 1912, Mr. Burton was employed for 18 years by the American Separator Co. and left to engage himself in the contracting business which he worked at up to the time of his death.  The deceased was a man of many keen interests and had a zest for sports, hunting, and his businesses.  He was fire chief of the local Fire Department at one time and also helped manage the town baseball team.  In 1918, he became a member of the Susquehanna Lodge, No. 167, F.&A.M., in which he continued membership for the rest of his life, winning the esteem of his fellow Masons, for his loyalty and honest interest. He was also a member of the local Chamber of Commerce and of the Episcopal Church. Aside from all these activities, however, the people who knew George Burton will remember him best for his hobby--cooking, his favorite pastime. For many years, all of Mr. Burton's entire summers were spent at Camp In-a-Vale, the summer lodge of Thomas Collins, which was located on the Susquehanna River.  Here he pursued to his heart's content, the culinary methods he constantly practiced and won still more friends with his adeptness in the kitchen.  Clam bakes were his specialty and few organizations in town have failed to contact George to preside at their baking fires.  he was always present to direct the preparation of food. We feel that the picture in this week's News is just how Bainbridgites want to remember their friend, his familiar smile, as he went down the river in a boat with supplies to cook at camp never changed despite worry of ill health and it was always ready for everyone.  Nearly two years ago, in January, Mr. Burton began suffering from severe attacks of asthma and his health failed steadily from that time up to last week when he failed to rally from an asthmatic spasm; death came at about 10 o'clock on Wednesday, Oct. 7.  Surviving besides his widow are two sons in the armed forces, Pvt. William Burton, of whom news was received by his father just before his passing, and who is somewhere with the A.E.F., and Gordon K. Burton, U.S. Navy, stationed at Augusta, Me.;  one daughter, Roberta Burton, of Bainbridge; a brother, Richard Burton, of Highland; and two sisters, Mrs. A.W. Tuckey, of this village, and Mrs. Morris Gardner, of Fly Creek.  His son, Gordon, arrived home immediately after having been notified, and it was, of course, impossible for Pvt. William to attend.  Funeral services were held Sunday at 1 P.M., in the Episcopal Church with Dr. Breese, of Green, officiating. A Masonic funeral was conducted in the church cemetery, with the R.W. Hugh Collins, past district deputy, leading.  Pall bearers were Lloyd Bluler, Harry Bluler, Harold Payne, Charles Peckham, Frank Lewis and James Ireland. The many floral tributes were material evidence of the  high esteem in which the deceased was held.  We in Bainbridge share the sorrow of the Burton family, and of the deceased let it be said:

"Weep not, sorrow not, at his absence--

But recall the light of his face.

And rejoice through your tears with the passing of years

For he goes to better some other place."

Obituaries (July 6)

James Conant Fosbury
Bainbridge Republican, April 20, 1872

In Memoriam:  The following is taken from the Daily Press of Iowa City, of April 8th, 1872:  "On Saturday occurred the death of James Conant Fosbury, in Iowa City, after an illness of thirteen weeks.  Mr. Fosbury was born in Chenango Co., N.Y., July 8, 1809, and came to this city in 1857. In 1862 he enlisted in the gray beard regiment and was mustered into service on the 31st of Oct. of that year, and followed the fortunes of his regiment during it three years service.  Mr. Fosbury was a consistent member of the Baptist church, and was known as a good and worthy citizen.  He was buried with military honors under the auspices of the G.A.R."  The deceased was son of Stephen Fosbury and brother of Reuben C. Fosbury, Esq., of Bainbridge.

Peter Snay

Bainbridge Republican, May 4, 1872

Masonville [Delaware Co., NY]:  Peter Snay, who was buried last week, was one of our oldest inhabitants perhaps the oldest in town.  His age was not far from 110 years.  He was the father of 21 children.

David Pearsall

Bainbridge Republican, June 6, 1878

David Pearsall, a respected resident of Bainbridge [Chenango Co., NY], and at one time Supervisor of the town, died at his residence on Tuesday morning of this week, aged 56 years.  His funeral took place on Wednesday, and was attended by a large concourse of relatives and friends.

Charles Pearsall

Afton Enterprise, Nov. 25, 1897

Coventryville [Chenango Co., NY]:  Hon. Charles Pearsall, who had been an invalid for the past three months, entered into rest on Wednesday at the age of 82 years.  He leaves a large circle of friends and relatives.  Especial sympathy is felt for the deeply afflicted widow, the son, Frank Pearsall, and daughter, Mrs. P.H. Parker.  He had been a strong man, physically, mentally and religiously and for many years was a very active and earnest worker in church and public affairs.  Until stricken this summer with physical debility he had continued to do a large share of the farm work with his son.  He had served in the capacity of assemblyman and various town offices.  About 1843 he united with the 1st Congregational church of this place and had since been one of the most influential members and until unable to attend he was almost invariably present at the various services in connection with the church and Sunday school, and contributed much to their prosperity and the advancement of religion in regard to church or local affairs and his able counsel was often sought.  Forty years he served as society clerk, a number of years as deacon and for over thirty years was a teacher in the Sunday school.  A sincere Christian, a kind and loving friend, a neighbor, husband and father has passed away and a vacant place is left that cannot be filled.  He bore with Christian patience his long and at times intensely painful illness, but as the days passed he longed to go home to his Savior. Though he can be with us no more, the influence of such a life will long continue. The funeral was held Saturday, conducted by his pastor Rev. R.C. Lansing.  Cor. Times.

Charles Cumber

Afton Enterprise, December 28, 1911

Coventryville [Chenango Co., NY]:  Charles Cumber died at his home here Wednesday p.m. after a long illness. Funeral at the house Friday p.m. with Rev. C. Sommerson of Coventry officiating.  Burial at Coventry.  He is survived by his wife and two daughters, Mrs. Fred Hinman and Mrs. Elmer Shapley, both of this town.

Death Notices

Bainbridge Republican, April 20, 1872

In Otego [Otsego Co., NY], April 5th, 1872, of consumption, Miss Ellen Hubbell, aged 19 years and 9 months.

In North Franklin [Delaware Co., NY], April 6, Wm. M. Gay, aged 51 years.

In Walton [Delaware Co., NY], March 30, Deacon Amos Hoyt, aged 76 years.

In Milford [Otsego Co., NY], April 1st, Wm. Queal, aged 80 years.

In Afton [Chenango Co., NY], John Musson, aged 75 years.

Marriages (July 4)

Marriage Notices

Source Unknown - April 1866

STRINGHAM - WEBB:  At the Chenango House in Greene [Chenango Co., NY] on the 29 ult. by Warren Gray, Esq., George W. Stringham of Binghamton [Broome Co., NY] to Lovina W. Webb of Smithville [Chenango Co., NY].

POTTER - WARNER:  In South Otselic [Chenango Co., NY] May 1, by Rev. D.V. Bowen, William C. Potter to Mary E. Warner, both of South Otselic.

BENTLY - NORTON:  May 1, by Rev. J.W. Barr, Hiland L. Bently, of Sandgate Vermont, to Louisa V. Norton, of German [Chenango Co, NY].

BLACKMAN - TOTMAN:  In Pharsalia [Chenango Co., NY], May 8, by Rev. J.W. Barr, Alonzo Blackman, of Plymouth [Chenango Co., NY] to Kate M. Totman, of Pharsalia.

Afton Enterprise, April 19, 1900

Butler - Woods

A quiet wedding took place at the Baptist parsonage Wednesday evening, April 11, when Mrs. Amelia Woods of Afton [Chenango Co., NY] and Mr. J.B. Butler of Canton, Pa.., were united in marriage by the Rev. D.C. Merrill.  Mr. and Mrs.Butler will reside in Canton where Mr. Butler is a leading business man.  He is City Justice and prominent in G.A.R. Circles.

Afton Enterprise, December 27, 1906
Tiffany - Terry & Tallmadge - Terry

Two couples were united in marriage at the M.E. Parsonage last Sunday morning, Dec. 23, by Rev. I.J. Smith.  Lavern E. Tiffany to Mabel A. Terry and Carlton Tallmadge to Helen E. Terry.

Mr. and Mrs. A.B. Smith

Bainbridge Republican, January 27, 1888

A.B. Smith, whose notice of his golden wedding will be found in another column, was married Jan. 19, 1838, at Guilford Centre, N.Y. [Chenango Co.], and he and his estimable wife immediately came to this village [Bainbridge, Chenango Co., NY], where Mr. Smith commenced blacksmithing, and from that time to the present he has ever been ready to "forge and weld" for his many customers.  Although for three or four years past Mr. Smith has worked but little, still the same muscular arm and many of the tools of half a century ago that earned the bread and made a home for his family of eight children, are not altogether idle, but ready almost any day to do a job of repairing.  How few there are who continue in the same line of business fifty years.

Golden Wedding:  Mr. and Mrs. A.B. Smith held an informal reception at their home on Kirby street [Bainbridge, Chenango Co., NY] last Thursday, it being the fiftieth anniversary of their marriage. The occasion was a very enjoyable one.  Of their five children, four were there to participate in the pleasures of the day.  One son, living in the far west, was unable to be present, but, we doubt not, was with them in spirit. Children, grandchildren, sisters, brothers, friends and neighbors united in offering their congratulations and wishes for a happy future.  Among the many presents was a gold headed cane and umbrella and $90 in gold coin.  Not the least noticeable was the refreshment room, where the table was heavily laden with most tempting viands, and the happy faces of the attendants proclaimed the marriage feast.  Mr. A.B. Smith and Miss Jane Baily were married at Guilford Centre, Jan. 19, 1838, by the Rev. Mr. Harmon.  Immediately after their marriage Mr. and Mrs. Smith came to this village [Bainbridge] where they have since resided.

Mr. and Mrs. A.B. Smith hereby acknowledge their grateful thanks to each and all those friends and neighbors who so kindly signified their remembrance of us by their greetings through calls, communications, and generous gifts at the celebration of the fiftieth anniversary of our married life.  Bainbridge, Jan. 20, 1888,  A.B Smith, Jane E. Smith

Mr. & Mrs. F.T. Seeley

Bainbridge Republican, January 27, 1888

Some of the many friends of Mr. and Mrs. F.T. Seeley gave to them a surprise upon their eleventh wedding anniversary, Tuesday Jan. 24th 1888.  The guests were sumptuously entertained and the inner man was abundantly refreshed. Afterward Mr. and Mrs. Seeley were presented with an elegant, velvet, Brussels couch, black walnut rocker, and other gifts, Rev. H.B. Cook, in a neat and appropriate speech, making the presentation.  Mr. and Mrs. Seeley both responded and expressed their pleasure at seeing so many of their old friends, unexpected though it was, and thanking them for their gifts, which spoke columns more than they could express of cemented friendship.

Obituaries (July 5)

Lana (Wright) Houck Hubbard

Afton Enterprise, February 8, 1900

Lana Hubbard died at the home of her daughter, Mrs. Robert Searles, in Afton [Chenango Co., NY]Feb. 4th, 1900.  Her maiden name was Lana Wright, and she was born in Seward, Schoharie Co., N.Y., April 8, 1821.  In 1840 she was married to John Houck of Seward.  Mrs. Searles being the only surviving child of that union.  Living a widow several years Mrs. Houck afterward married Mr. Oliver Hubbard of Elk Creek, Otsego Co. with whom she lived eighteen years. After his death she made her home with Mr. and Mrs. Robert Searles of Afton.  these were years of suffering for the mother and of care for the daughter and her husband, and well did they fulfill their mission of loving care.  Some of the last of her life were scenes of intense suffering.  Ofttimes in some of her lucid moments she was heard trying to sing snatches of those old hymns which have cheered many a dying Christian.

"Rock of Ages cleft for me

let me hide myself in thee."

"Bring forth the Royal Diadem

And crown Him Lord of all."

So daughter and loving friends are happy to think at the last, that her thought and song laid hold of "The mighty to Save and the "Glorified One."  She was buried from the home of Robert Searles, East side, Afton, Feb. 6th, Rev. B.B. Carruth conducting the services.  A.J. Holmes, funeral director of Afton was in charge, and burial in beautiful Glenwood [Afton, NY].

William Merritt

Afton Enterprise, February 8, 1900

News was received late Tuesday evening of the death of William Merritt brother of Mrs. Fred Davis of Harpursville and Mrs. John Chamberlin, of this place.  He was employed by the Shakers and when they sold out at Windsor he moved with Mr. Shaw to New Lebanon [Columbia Co., NY] where he has since been living.

Stephen Johnson

Afton Enterprise, March 15, 1900

Stephen Johnson, formerly of this section [Wilkins Settlement] died suddenly Monday morning, March 5th at the home of his daughter, Mrs. John lee, near Coventryville [Chenango Co., NY] aged 85 years.  Burial at North Afton [Chenango Co., NY], Rev. A. McIntyre officiating.

Truman Higley

Afton Enterprise, March 15, 1900

After an illness of five months from heart affection, Truman Higley died this morning at the Park Hotel his residence for the past five years.  Truman Higley was born in Canton, Conn. in 1837 where he resided until 1856 when in company with his brother, Walter Higley, he moved to Bainbridge. The funeral services will be held at his late residence, the Park Hotel, Friday afternoon at 1:30. Services private for family and immediate friends.

Augusta Easton

Afton Enterprise, April 26, 1900

Miss Augusta Easton died at the home of her brother, D.B. Easton in West Bainbridge [Chenango Co., NY] Wednesday morning of last week aged about 56.  The funeral services were held Friday and the burial was in Glenwood [Afton, Chenango Co., NY].  Miss Easton has been a life long resident of this village and enjoyed the esteem of all.

Howard A. Salisbury

Afton Enterprise, March 29, 1900

The sad intelligence reached this village last Thursday evening that Howard A. Salisbury of Bainbridge [Chenango Co., NY] had been instantly killed in a freight wreck on the D.&H. at Harpursville station. The details of the accident are at this time probably known by nearly all of our readers.  Mr. Salisbury had gone to Binghamton on Tuesday in reference to a situation he had anticipated securing and was returning to Bainbridge when the accident occurred. Being well known to the employees on the road he chose to ride on a through freight in company with a friend.  He was sitting at the end of a car loaded with steel rails, chatting away as the train was approaching Harpursville station between 5 and 6 o'clock.  A wheel of that same car broke and in the lunge of the car one foot was caught in the rails which prevented his escape by jumping.  A wreck of the train followed, several cars being piled up.  His associate had a foot caught also, but was able to extricate himself by pulling his foot out of a congress shoe which he wore and then jumped thereby saving his life.  Being pinioned by the rails he was held fast until the heavy weight of the rails coming upon him, his life was crushed out.  One leg was severed but he was not otherwise badly mutilated.  It was several hours before his body could be taken from the wreck, when the remains were taken to his home in Bainbridge in charge of Undertaker Ramsdell.  He is survived by his mother, Mrs. George R. Salisbury, upon whom the blow falls with crushing force.  Howard, who was aged 24 years, was popular with all and his loss is most keenly felt.  He was a member of the Empire State Quartet which has sung in Afton on many occasions and he had also assisted the M.E. choir winning the esteem of its members who showed their respect by attending the funeral which occurred on Saturday afternoon. They carried as a tribute an elegant flower piece. The services which were largely attended were conducted by Rev. Arthur Spalding and Rev. C.D. Reed. The selections of music were rendered by Mrs. Charlotte Buck, Mrs. Ralph Kirby, William Hart and Wm. Carruth of Afton.  Miss Minnie VanCott was the accompanist with instrumental music.

The funeral of Howard Salisbury, who was killed in the D.&H. wreck at Harpursville on Thursday was held at the home of Mrs. E.M. Warren on North Main street on Saturday afternoon, Rev. Arthur Spaulding officiating. Burial in St. Peter's cemetery [Bainbridge, Chenango Co., NY].

July 4th 1879,. Bainbridge & Sidney Plains

Bainbridge Republican, July 10 1879

July 4th, 1879 in Bainbridge

Calm and serene was the birthday of the ever glorious in Bainbridge.  Neither the canon's boom, the rockets red glare, booms bursting in air, nor even the youth's fascinator, the Chinese cracker, rang out on the stilly night, as the clock revealed the anniversary of that Day when tried the souls of all true patriots, and the Nation stood 108 years old.  A few of the boys, awakened to a sense of the importance of the occasion had, early on the evening of the 3d, paraded the streets with the paraphernalia of the Continentals--tin pans, horns, etc.; but even their patriotism waned ere the hour of midnight, and the day was remarkable for naught save its quiet and serenity. During the day the streets were nearly deserted, save by an occasional bacchanal, who endeavored to keep up the '76 spirit by pouring down that of '79.  But there were but few even of these misguided patriots to be seen, and the day generally had the appearance of a sea coast town during the cod fishing season. Several of our citizens went to Sidney to join in the celebration there, but found but few more people than they had left at home. The program was well carried out, however, and lacked only the multitude to make it a perfect success.  Mr. Danforth's oration, was appreciated by those present, and heartily applauded.  Those believing an occasional war whoop preferable to unbroken quietude, should have gone to Sidney; but those who glory in repose--noonday siesta, and all that sort of thing, Bainbridge was the haven they should have sought.  It will long be remembered by the youth as the year "when the Fourth didn't come to Bainbridge."

July 4th 1879 in Sidney Plains

The 4th of July celebration at this place proved a pleasant and interesting affair. The oration by Elliot Danforth, Esq., of Bainbridge, was not only an able production but one replete with erudition, and confirms the already oft expressed opinion, "that for oratorical capabilities Mr. Danforth has few equals."  The reading of the declaration of Independence, as well as the introductory remarks, by T.G. Smith, were excellent. The Chaplain, Rev. Samuel Johnson done honor to himself for the nobel and national sprit which he manifested on the occasion. The Unadilla "Cornet Band" are also deserving of much praise for their gentlemanly deportment and willingness to contribute interest on the occasion by their prompt response with music, voluntarily or when requested, and for their genial presence until the closing exercises in the evening. The Fusilier parade was a grand success, and was highly spoken of by all who witnessed it, the characters represented were well sustained, and the "getters up" are entitled to much credit for their good exhibition of the semi-comic-ridiculous. The display of  fire works was fine, and it was estimated that nearly 1000 people were present during this portion of the entertainment.  And we are only to chronicle one slight accident during the day, and that consisted of a young man by the name of Peaslee, getting his hand powder blown in firing off an anvil.  There was also observable in the evening a few old land soakers who had succeeded in obtaining a little "somethin" from some where, that made them feel "kinder natural like," otherwise no disorderly conduct was witnessed, to mar the pleasure of anyone.  We noticed quite a number of visitors from adjoining towns, and especially from Bainbridge, among whom were the Proprietary, Editor, wife and child, and the printers "devil" of the Republican. The Marshals of the day... discharged their duties well and made fine appearance upon their horses, particularly "Joe," who with his full Zouave uniform of the old 53 regiment, appeared as tho' he felt at home.  And taken all in all, the program was well carried out, but of course in getting up a celebration, the great bulk of work and trouble necessarily burdens itself upon a limited few, who do not really wish to shirk a responsibility, and in this instance none are deserving of more praise for their untiring efforts and hard labor than S.L. Fisher, chairman of the committee of arrangements, and the only failure we have cognizance of in connection with the celebration was that of a self conceited individual who thought that by withholding his purse and influence could annihilate the 4th of July.

Obituaries (July 4)

Dr. Henry Gleason Gibbs
1830 - 1866

GIBBS:  in Washington, D.C., April 6th, at the residence of his brother-in-law, Dr. S.A.H. McKim, after a painful and lingering illness with consumption, Dr. Henry Gleason Gibbs, a native of Norwich, Chenango county [NY].

If purity of character, sterling integrity, faithfulness in the discharge of duties, and a perfect resignation to the will of Providence, in all his trials and disappointments, and bearing testimony with the expiring breath that there is peace in believing, should bring consolation to the hearts of the mourners, then few have firmer grounds for their consolation than the friends and acquaintances of Henry Gibbs.  Early "called to a knowledge of the truth as it is in Jesus," the consistency of his life, and the steadfastness of purpose to all the deep waters through which he was led, are such evidences of the truth of the religion, and the power of God, that "those who love the Lord," and knew the subject of these thoughts will derive pleasure and profit in dwelling on his trials and afflictions and praise God that His grace still sustains and comforts his humble followers and should stimulate us to emulate his pious life, through the same source of power.   McK. Washington D.C., April 9, 1866

Sarah Post

1799 - 1866

POST:  In Pitcher [Chenango Co., NY], April 21, Sarah [Post], consort of Dea. Levi Post, in the 68th year of her age.

She had long been a faithful Christian, and a consistent member of the Baptist church of Christ.  Her faith, and hope and love were firm and supporting to the last.  In her death the neighborhood has lost  a valuable neighbor, and a reliable friend, and the Chruch, a living and substantial member.  It may well be said of her, "She hath done what she could.  Her end was peace."   R.D.P.

Arthur L. Palmatier

1876 - 1943

Funeral services at 2:00 at the Grimes Church for Arthur L. Palmatier who died on Saturday August 7th, 1943 at the home of his son Roy Palmatier of Pine Grove from complications which caused an illness of several months duration. Arthur was born here and has lived in this section his entire lifetime following the occupation of lumbering in this and nearby places.  He has resided at Betula, Wrights and Smethport and has won friends on everyside by his quiet unassuming manner and ready helpfulness to any and all of those in need with whom he associated.  He was born in this place December 15, 1876 and was the son of Peter and Margaret (Springstead) Palmatier well known and highly respected early residents.  He was married to Miss Elsie Kilcoin who survives with the following sons and daughters: Roy of this place, Clifford of Emporium and Leonard of the United States navy and three daughters, Vada of Akron O., Lila of Cleveland, Ohio and Frances at their home in Betula.  Five were present at the funeral services, Leonard at present being on a trip overseas.  He is also survived by nieces and nephews and other near kindred by whom he will be greatly missed. The funeral rites were well attended with the Rev. Earl Williams pastor of the local First Baptist church officiating.  Mrs. Everett Card and Mrs. Edward McElwee sang a couple of appropriate hymns "Beautiful Isle of Somewhere" and the "Old Rugged Cross" with Mrs. Williams accompanist. Burial was made in the family plot of the Grimes Cemetery with the following acting as casket bearers:  Messrs. Everett Card, Paul Ostrander, Charles Nunn, Archie Austin, Delbert Baxter and James Speigel.

Roy Palmatier

1902 - 1951

Death claimed Roy A. Palmatier Friday morning March 16, 1951, at 11:25 at the Bradford Hospital as the result of internal injuries received while at work on a logging project at Coryville.  Death resulted from a crushed chest and shock received in an accident at Coryville late Thursday afternoon.  Mr. Palmatier was operating a tractor hauling logs from a small lumbering project when the vehicle slid into a ditch releasing the log boom, which snapped upward striking the victim in the chest.  Francis E. Cummings, son-in-law of Mr. Palmatier, who was working with him when the accident occurred, summoned additional aid to extricate the fatally injured man, and also had an ambulance call sent out.  It is reported that it required about 45 minutes to free Mr. Palmatier from between the boom and the tractor.

Mr. Palmatier was born at Wrights, Pa., on September 19, 1902, and had spent his entire life in this vicinity, following the lumber business.  He married Mrs. Louise Pritt at Johnstown, Pa., on April 26, 1944, who survives with the following children:  Mrs. Marjorie Harvey of Rock City, Mrs. Shirley Woodruff and Miss Thelma of Eldred; three stepdaughters, Mrs. Louise Kazimer, Mrs. Rosemarie Cummings and Mrs. Wanita Lane, all of Port Allegany; five grandchildren, Joseph, Louise and Jacqueline Kazimer of Port Allegany and Susan Harvey of Rock City, and Roger Woodruff of Eldred.  He is also survived by his mother, Mrs. Elsie Palmatier, Port Allegany, and the following brothers and sisters; Clifford of Williamsport, Mrs. Vada Brook of Akron, O., Leonard, Mrs. Lila Hadden and Francis, all of Port Allegany.

Prayer services were held at his home in Pine Grove Monday afternoon at 2 p.m. followed by services in the United Brethren church of Port Allegany, by the Rev. J. Westley.  Burial was in the Fairview cemetery with the following as pallbearers:  Paul Manning, Leo Meacham, William Clark, Dominic Tronetti, Bruno Graziano and Gus Hagstrom.

Death Notices

Source Unknown - April 1866

QUIVEY:  In Brookfield [Madison Co., NY], May 6, of spotted fever, Jennie [Quivey], only daughter of M.S. Quivey, aged 6 years, formerly of this place.

McKIM:  In Washington, D.C. April 29th, James [McKim], youngest child of Dr. S.A.H. and Caroline L. McKim aged 1 year.

PARKER:  In Norwich [Chenango Co., NY], on the 2d inst., Mary Parker, wife of the late Sylvanus Parker, aged 77 years.  [Buried White Store Cemetery]

SMITH:  In Preston [Chenango Co., NY], May 4, Charles M. [Smith], son of Frederick H Smith, aged 3(?) years.

Blog Post Listing, June 18 to July 3, 2018

Marriages

Posted June 19, 2018

Nellie B. Hubbard - Fred A. Quackenbos (Norwich, 1926)

Russell E. Tiffany - Molly Evelyn Gregory (Norwich/Wadesboro NC, 1942)

Patricia Lucille Harper - William M. White (Norwich, 1942)

Marriage notices - 1875

     Frank Pellett - Mary Edgar (Norwich/Sidney)

     Harrison A. Palmer - Nellie Janet Reed (Sherburne)

     George H. Adams - Nora B. Smith (Rockdale/Binghamton)

     John F. Bishop - Jennie Frazer (Harpersville/Oxford)

Posted June 24, 2018
Bigamy of Ellsworth Ward -1907 (Bainbridge, Binghamton, Norwich)

Posted June 29, 2018
Carol Ann LeSuer - Roger Sterling Armstrong (Afton, 1957)
Dr. W.J. LeSuer - Lizzie LeSuer (Oneonta/Afton, 1893)
Helen Morgan - Kenneth James Conner (North Afton/North Pitcher, 1934)
Marriage Notices
     Benjamin Davis - Elvia LeSure (Afton, 1875)
     James LeSuer - M.A. Somers (Afton/Deansville, 1896)

Obituaries

Posted June 18, 2018

Rev. Harold M. Quincy (Troy, Norwich, 1942)

Alfred R. Quinn (Norwich, 1947)

James LeSuer (Norwich, 1933)

Edward E. Jones (Binghamton, Afton, 1933)

Raymond J. Dickinson (New York Mills, 1944)

Posted June 20, 2018
Cornelia Sheffel (Clay, 1849)
Jared A. Bailey (Norwich, South New Berlin, 1926)
Edward E. Murray (Rockdale, 1929)
Death Notices - 1949
     Julia Sutton Morse (Guilford)
     Leo C. Winsor (Guilford)

Posted June 21, 2018
Imogene Whitbeck (Sodus, 1849)
Richard Elwood Stover (Smyrna, 1873)  Tree cutting accident
Edward P. Hilliard (McDonough, 1873)  drowning accident
Reynolds Theron Reed (Unadilla, Coventry, Binghamton, 1873)

Posted June 22, 2018
Betsey Nichols (Portageville, 1849)
Lois B. Dayton (Wellsville, 1849)
Ellen Minerva Wade (Norwich, Guilford, 1951)
Helen R. (Johnson) Chadwick (Morristown, Guilford, 1951)
John C. Dimorier (Windsor, Afton, 1951)
Evelyn C. (Harrington) Hallock (Gkuilford, Wellsbridge, 1951)

Posted June 24, 2018
Harriet Howey (Canandaigua, 1849)
Leland B. Carpenter (Edmeston, 1918)
Charles Strasser (Norwich, 1918)  drowning accident
William George Kenney (NYC, Norwich, 1918)  drowning accident
Ray LeSuer (Afton, 1941)  Falling tree accident
Death Notices - 1894
     Phebe Ann Beecher (Norwich, 85y)
     Bridget Clunan (Norwich, 52y)
     Morton A. Sage (Norwich, 21y)
     Charles Russell Terry, (Norwich, 4y)

Posted June 25, 2018
Fred LeSuer (Afton, 1910)
Una (Stilson) Shay (Cobleskill, Afton, 1920)
Elida (Snell) LeSuer (Afton, 1920)

Posted June 28, 2018
Wallace LeSuer (Afton, 1889)
Caroline LeSuer (Bennettsville, 1899)
Betsey A. (LeSuer) Butler (Afton, 1900)
Blanche LeSuer (Afton, Norwich, 1934)
Arthur LeSuer (Afton, 1934)
S. Wells LeSuer (Afton, 1956)
Death Notices
     Pasque LeSur (Afton, 1888, 65y)
     Lepha O. LeSuer (Afton, 1896, 69y)
     Ida LeSuer (Afton, 1951, 88y)

Posted June 30, 2018
Ida E. LeSuer (Afton, Bainbridge, 1946)
Elbert LeSuer (Afton, 1952)
Mabel Tuttle (Coventry, North Colesville, 1909)
Lyman LeSuer (Afton, 1911)
Death Notices - 1885
     Betsey Paddleford (Glenaubrey, 85y)
     George Hodge (Coventryville)
     Libbie Sands (Bainbridge)
     Mr. T.M. Blair (Bainbridge)
     Daniel Campbell (Bainbridge)
     John C. Bliven (New Berlin, 68y)
     Roderick Dibble (Preston, Bainbridge, 60y)
     Thomas Green (Preston, Pharsalia, 65y)
     Abagail Devoe (Bainbridge, 47y)
     John E. Whitmroe (Guilford, 78y)

Posted July 2, 2018
Albert C. Latham (Guilford, Norwich, 1883)
Harriet A. Godfrey (Sherburne, 1883)
Walter A. Potts (Sidney, Norwich, 1883)
Jennie E. Dexter (Norwich, 1883)

Posted July 3, 2018
Francis Jenette (Church) Johnston (Afton, 1890)
Amelia Clapper (Afton, 1904)
George W. Obenauer (Norwich, 1955)
Fannie M. (Shay) Martin (Oxford, Afton, 1957)
George R. Shay (Thompson PA, 1959)
Death Notices - 1886
     Eleanor (Shay) Johnston (Afton, 73y)
Death notices - 1894
     Phebe Ann Beecher (Norwich, 85y)
     Bridget Clunan (Norwich, 52y)
     Morton A. Sage (Norwich, 21y)
     Charles Russell Terry (Norwich, 4y)
   

Miscellaneous

Posted June 18, 2018

Murder of William Druse, 1894, Part 4

Posted June 19, 2018
Famous People Chenango County has given to the World - Daniel S. Dickinson
The Murder of William Druse, Part 5, Pardon of Mary Druse.

Posted June 23, 2018
Murder of William Druse, 1894, Part 6, Druse Ghosts

Posted July 1, 2018
Mysterious Death of Mabel Tuttle, Delhi, NY - 1906

Obituaries (July 3)

Frances Jenette Church Johnston

Afton Enterprise, January 23, 1890

Mrs. E.M. Johnston, of Afton [Chenango Co., NY], died Tuesday night, of pneumonia, aged 58 years. 

Afton Enterprise, January 30, 1890

The funeral of Mrs. E.M. Johnston, mention of whose death we made in our last issue, was held from her late home in Bettsburg, Sunday, and was largely attended.  Mrs. Johnston was one of the finest ladies in the town, and she will be greatly missed by a large circle of friends and relatives. She leaves a husband, four sons and one daughter. The burial was in the cemetery on the east side.  Rev. D. Lamphear officiating.  C.H. Emens was funeral director.

Amelia Clapper

Afton Enterprise, February 25, 1904

At the home of E.M. Shay on South Main street Saturday, Feb. 20, 1904, occurred the death after an illness of two days from valvular heart trouble of Miss Amelia Clapper, aged 71 years.  Miss Clapper was a life long resident of Afton [Chenango Co., NY] and for some forty years had made her home with Mr. Shay's people.  Deceased was a member since youth of St. Ann's Episcopal church in which she was a faithful worker, and for many years was choir organist.  She was known and respected by everyone.  Funeral services, conducted by Rev. Edwin l. Tanner were held from St. Ann's church Tuesday forenoon at 10:30 o'clock.  Members of the choir from St. Luke's church in Harpursville assisted in the singing.  Interment was made in the family lot in Glenwood cemetery [Afton, NY]

Mary E. (Holmes) Obenauer

1873 - 1955

Mrs. Mary E. Holmes Obenauer, 81, of 75 East Main Street [Norwich, Chenango Co., NY], widow of George W. Obenauer died at the Chenango Memorial Hospital at 12:45 this afternoon. She was born September 13, 1873, in Poolville, the daughter of Americus A. and Nancy Stratton Holmes.  She was married to George W. Obenauer June 12, 1895, in Norwich.  He died March 8, 1950.  She had made her home at the present address for the past 35 years.  Mrs. Obenauer was a charter member of Norwich Chapter 367, Order of Eastern Star, and was a member of the First Congregational Church. She is survived by a son, Dr. F. Holmes Obenauer of Malone; a daughter, Marjorie Anita Obenauer, of Boston, Mass., two brothers, Clark Holmes of Poolville and George Holmes of Port Byron; a sister-in-law, Mrs. George Hudson of Clinton; two nephews, Harry Holmes, Schenectady, and Grant Holmes of Scotia; two nieces, Mrs. Earl Bristol, Syracuse, and Gertrude Holmes, of Washington, D.C.; also several cousins. The body is at the Robert J. Fahy Funeral Home from where funeral and committal services will be held at 2 p.m. Thursday, the Rev. Avery D. Post, pastor of the First congregational Church, officiating.  The body will be placed in the family vault in Mt. Hope Cemetery [Norwich, NY].

Fannie M. (Shay) Martin

1859 -1957

Mrs. Fannie M. Martin, 98, of Oxford [Chenango Co., NY] died at 11:48 a.m. yesterday at Sunny Vale Nursing Home, Oxford RD, after a long illness.  She is survived by a daughter, Mrs. C.L. Hallock of Oxford; six grandchildren; nine great-grandchildren; a sister, Mrs. Edna Stillman of Binghamton, and several nieces and nephews.  She was a member at Harpursville Methodist church for 70 years. The body was moved to the Karschner Funeral home, Afton [Chenango Co., NY]

George R. Shay

1876 - 1959

George R. Shay, 83, of Thompson, Pa., RD1, died Sunday at St. Joseph's Hospital, Carbondale, Pa., after a long illness.  Born in Susquehanna County, Pa., he had been a resident in the Thompson area for the last 45 years.  He is survived by his wife, Mrs. Edith Shay of the same address; two sons, Nathan Shay of Binghamton and Milton Shay of Herrick Center, Pa.; three step-sons, John Hendrickson of Carbondale, Russell Hendrickson, of Friendsville, Pa., and Benson Davis of Thompson; two step-daughters, Mrs. Homer Painter and Mrs. Glenford Carpenter, both of Binghamton; two grandchildren and several nieces and nephews.  Mr. Shay was a member of the Ararat Methodist Church and of Thompson Grange 862. The body was taken to the Mumford Funeral Home, Starrucca, Pa., where friends may call.

Death Notices

Afton Enterprise, May 7, 1886

Mrs. Eleanor Johnston, a highly respected lady of this town, died Monday afternoon of this week, aged 73 years.  Her funeral was held Wednesday and the remains were deposited in the cemetery on the east side of the river.

Chenango Union, October 4, 1894

BEECHER:  In Norwich [Chenango Co., NY], Sept. 29, 1894 Phebe Ann [Beecher], widow of Harry Beecher, age 85. Burial in Coventry [Chenango Co., NY].

CLUNAN:  In Norwich [Chenango Co., NY], Sept. 27, 1894, Bridget [Clunan], wife of Thomas Clunan, age 52 years.

SAGE:  In Norwich [Chenango Co., NY], Sept. 27, 1894, Mr. Morton A. Sage, age 21 years.

TERRY:  In Norwich [Chenango Co., NY], Sept. 27, 1894 Charles Russell [Terry], son of Hiram and Margaret Terry, age 4 years, 5 months 7 days.

Obituaries (July 2)

Harriet A. Godfrey

Chenango Union, May 17, 1883

Sherburne [Chenango Co., NY]:  The sudden, though not wholly unexpected demise of Mrs. Harriet A. Godfrey on Monday last is a source of grief to this community.  Her daughter, Alice, coming home from school after the close of the afternoon session, found her lying upon the floor without evidence of life and at once summoned assistance.  Upon examination it was discovered that life was entirely extinct. The dinner table had not been disturbed since the noon day meal and it is thought that the deceased lady had been dead for several hours at the time of her daughter's arrival. being subject to heart disease, the attending physician had previously predicted the fate which befell her. Mrs. Godfrey was born in Sullivan co., N.Y., was united in marriage to W.C. Godfrey in December 1851, has resided in Sherburne with her family for the past twelve years, and was a sincere and faithful member of the M.E. Chruch in this village. As a wife, mother, neighbor and Christian her life was fruitful of kindness and good works.

Albert C. Latham

Chenango Union, May 17, 1883

Another of our old and esteemed citizens has been called to his reward.  Albert C. Latham died at his residence on Monday evening last, aged fifty-five years. Deceased was the only son of the late John Latham, and was born in Guilford [Chenango Co., NY].  In 1842 his father was elected County Clerk, and removed with his family to this village [Norwich, Chenango Co., NY].  Since that time, with the exception of a few years spent in the west, he has resided in this village and was for a time a partner with the late Ralph Johnson in the hardware trade.  In 1864 he entered the National Bank of Norwich as bookkeeper, and afterwards became teller, which position he held until a few months since, when compelled by failing health to relinquish it.  In all the relations of life he was a strictly upright, conscientious man. For many years an active member of the Baptist church, he has discharged the duties of librarian and superintendent of the Sunday School with marked ability and endeared himself to this association by his consistent Christian life. As a business man he was industrious, correct and thorough.  Socially, he was genial, courteous, companionable.  He will be missed in our community, but how sadly in the home circle, where his stricken widow mourns  his departure.  Funeral services will be held at his late residence on Hayes Street, Thursday afternoon at four o'clock, Rev.  H.A. Delano officiating.

Walter A. Potts

Chenango Union, May 17, 1883

On Friday evening last, Walter A. Potts, for several years foreman of the bridge corps of the N.Y.O.&W railroad, with headquarters in this village [Norwich, Chenango Co., NY], died at Sidney [Delaware Co., NY] where for a few months past he had been engaged in the flour and feed business.  His remains were taken to Pennellville, Oswego County, his former home, on Saturday evening.  A special train left this station on the N.Y.O.&W. road at nine o'clock on Sunday morning, with some thirty-six Knights of Norwich Commandery, of which deceased was a member, and a number of others for Pennellville, where the funeral was to take place in the afternoon.  Other members of the order took the train at stations on the route.  The remains were conveyed from the residence of his brother-in-law to the little village church, in charge of the Sir Knights, who were joined by members of other Commanderies, and by some fifty members of Phoenix Lodge of Masons, as well as by a number of railroad employees from Oswego and Fulton.  The church was crowded with sympathizing friends from the surrounding country.  An able discourse was delivered by Rev. A.J. Hutchins of Syracuse, whose closing remarks relating to the order there represented were timely and touchingly expressed. At the close of the services, those of the knights Templar were performed by Past Em. Sir 13 Gage Berry, as Commander, and Sir knight Whitman Clarke, as Prelate. A quartette composed of Messrs. Ed L. Nash, J.B. Merrick and Clarence Cary, of this village, and Charles Hurburt, of Sherburne, added to the interest of the services, both at the church and at the cemetery, by their singing of the appropriate odes. A large number of citizens accompanied the remains to the cemetery, where they were deposited in the family lot, the impressive Templar burial service being conducted by the proper officers. The train returned after the services reaching Norwich at 7:30. Deceased was an active business man, and was much esteemed by all who knew him. he was marred some three years ago,  and his wife died four months after the marriage.  his age was thirty-six years.

Jennie E. Dexter

Chenango Semi-Weekly Telegrpah, November 7, 1883

Jennie E. [Dexter], only daughter of George W. and Pardetis Dexter, died at her father's residence at 1:30 o'clock A.M.  Deceased was born in South New Berlin [Chenango Co., NY] September 6, 1868 and hence was in her 16th year.  When she was about three years old her parents removed to Guilford, which has since been her home. For nearly five weeks she had been confined to her bed with chronic laryngitis.  She was apparently improving until the Sunday preceding her death and it was not until Wednesday that her physician lost hopes of her recovery.  Jennie was a general favorite with her companions, and by her quiet and lady like bearing she won the esteem of her seniors.  It can be truly said of her that she always acted as she thought was right. When such as one falls, silence most becomes us, tears are the most befitting eulogy.  The funeral services were conducted by the Rev. P.R. Tower, at the M.E. Church on Sunday.  The church was crowded with sympathizing friends. At 12 o'clock the remains were borne up the aisle by the remaining members of the Sunday School class of which she was a member, following these came the relatives and immediately after them the public school in a body. A soon as the casket had been placed in position Misses Anna Warrener and May Dickinson stepped forward and placed upon the lid a beautiful floral cross, a tribute from the teachers and pupils of the school.  The services were of a very impressive nature and scarcely a dry eye was to be seen in the audience.  At the conclusion of the services, the remains were born to the cemetery accompanied by the relatives, friends and school.  Here was committed to the earth "dust to dust, ashes to ashes," the body of one who was true to herself, true to her friends, true to her God.

Mysterious Death of Mabel Tuttle - 1906

She Loved Not Wisely, But Too Well

Newburgh NY Register, December 1906

A very sad case, resembling in many ways that of Grace Brown, has just transpired near Delhi, [Delaware Co.] in which the victim of too much faith in man was Miss Mabel Tuttle, a farmer's handsome daughter, who about to become a mother, ended her life by some unknown vegetable poison. The miscreant responsible is said to be Carl Richards of Oneonta, who disappeared as soon as the girl's death was made public.  He had known her from babyhood, and her father purchased his farm from his father. The girl's mother recently visited another daughter, Mrs. Meehan.  at Otisville, and bought some silk for a waist for Mabel there, as Richards had promised to marry Mabel. The girl had clumsily attempted to bring about the death of her child in addition to taking poison.

Delhi Girl's Mysterious Death - A Rigid Investigation Will Follow

The Otsego Farmer, December 7, 1906

Mabel Tuttle, nineteen years old who resided on a farm with her parents near Delhi, Delaware county, is dead under such circumstances that the coroner is making the most rigid kind of an investigation into the circumstances leading up to the tragedy.  She was but nineteen years old, a student in the high school last year and up to a short time ago, she was preparing to be married on December 3 to one Carl Richards of Oneonta. A few days since preparations for the wedding were stopped.  An autopsy failed to establish the cause of death and a chemical analysis is to be made of the contents of the stomach.

Monday afternoon Mrs. John Meehan of Ottsville, a married sister of Mabel, returned to the Tuttle home to spend Thanksgiving and Tuesday night the sisters slept together.  Mrs. Meehan says that they did not wake up until daylight.  Mrs. Meehan remarked that it was late and she then proceeded to dress.  Mabel sat up in bed.  While Mrs. Meehan was standing in front of the mirror, Mabel suddenly exclaimed "Oh Annis!" and sank back unconscious on her pillow.  Mr. and Mrs. Tuttle were at the barn milking and Mrs. Meehan at once rushed out and summoned them to the bedside of the stricken girl.  They found her in an unconscious condition and thought she lived for an hour, she never rallied from that condition.  Dr. William Ormiston of Delhi was summoned and when he arrived at the house the girl had passed away.

The coroner who is Dr. P.L. Craig of Davenport, assisted by Drs. H.A. Gates and William Ormiston performed an autopsy.  This was concluded on Thursday afternoon.  The viscera was removed from the body, sealed up and sent to Albany for chemical analysis.  Though the physicians did not find anything which they could certify as to the cause of death, they did find that the girl would have become a mother in four months.  And it was also ascertained that death did not follow as the result of a criminal operation.

From letters found among the girl's effects it was evident that someone signing the name of Carl Richards of Oneonta was, according to the writer's admissions, the coroner ways, responsible for the girl's condition.  But a significant and to the authorities an all important fact is that the correspondence apparently ended about a month ago.  In the last letter written over a month ago, the writer said he would arrive on December 4, and to it he renewed his declarations of love and fealty.  In previous letters he had said that he would keep his promise.  Richards is said to be a member of a well-to-do family in Oneonta.  He came to this neighborhood last June and spent a month with a family residing two miles from this village and it was on this visit that he is alleged to have made the acquaintance of Mabel Tuttle. But for this meeting, it is said that the girl would have today been a student in the Delhi high school.  The Tuttle family physician is Dr. H.J. Goodrich.  He is in New York, but it is said that he had not attended any member of the family in a month.  The inquest will be continued after the report as to the contents of the stomach ahs been received.  It was at first thought that she may have committed suicide.  

In Oneonta Richards is well known.  Inquiry for him on Friday revealed that he had not been seen in Oneonta since the day previous. At his home it was said that he left town on Thursday and his whereabouts were not known.  His father, Lyman Richards, said that he had no knowledge that the young man was engaged to be married and knew of no intimacy with Mabel Tuttle.  He had heard nothing of the approaching marriage. The only information in relation to the matter was the receipt of a telephone message received about noon Friday, stating that Mable Tuttle was dead and the funeral would be held on Saturday. The younger Richards has been a wayward fellow and his companions here will not believe that he seriously intended to be married.

The inquest was opened in Delhi on Wednesday of this week.  It is learned that Miss Tuttle had visited recently in Oneonta and had been entertained at Richards' home.

Coroner's Inquest in Delhi Girl's Death

Utica Herald-Dispatch, December 7, 1906

Oneonta:  An investigation of the cause of the death of Mabel Tuttle of Delhi, who died under peculiar circumstances November 28, has been commenced by Coroner Craig of Delaware County, who, after the examination of several witnesses adjourned the inquest to December 19.

The testimony of the doctors who performed the autopsy, Dr. Gates and Dr. Ormiston, was that an operation of a criminal nature had been performed upon the girl from 24 to 36 hours before her death.  While both said that it might have been done by the girl herself, they swore that it was not probable that she could have done it.

The first witness sworn was the father of the dead girl, William N. Tuttle. he stated that Mabel had been at home the greater part of the past year, with the exception of her visit to the Richards family in Oneonta in the middle of last August. She had also assisted in housework at the family of a neighbor for two weeks.  Came home from there about the first of November and had been home since that time.  he was not aware of her condition until, as near as he could remember, about the 15th of October.

Anna Tuttle, mother of the girl, corroborated the testimony of her husband.  

Mrs. Charles Rice, another sister of the deceased gave testimony of no special important.  

The doctors were unable to determine positively the cause of death from the autopsy.

Investigation Will Probably Die

The Hobart independent, December 22, 1906

Delhi:  The investigation by the authorities into the death of Mable Tuttle, whose sudden demise, under peculiar circumstances is fresh in the minds of readers, will probably die.  Coroner Craig and District Attorney Neish who have investigated the matter extendedly, think it is improbable that any person can be convicted of any crime in the death of the girl. While she undoubtedly came to her death as the result of an attempt to relieve her delicate condition, yet evidence incriminating anyone would be difficult to secure.