Chenango Union, Norwich, NY, May 15, 1879
Marriages
TITUS - WARNER: At the residence of the bride's father, in Norwich [Chenango Co. NY], May 8th, by Rev. S. Scoville, Mr. Charles H Titus of North Norwich to Miss Edith A Warner of Norwich.
SCHORN - YOUNG: In Columbus [Chenango Co. NY] May 7th, by Rev. C.A. Stone, Mr. Francis J. Schorn of Norwich [Chenango Co NY] to Miss Edith A. Young of Columbus.
JACKSON - LANSING: In Greene [Chenango Co. NY] by Rev. S.T. Ford, Mr. Truman H. Jackson to Miss Elsie W. Lansing, all of Greene.
WOOD - COWLES: In Greene [Chenango Co. NY] April 30th, by Rev. G.A. Pelton, Mr. Horace J. Wood to Mrs. Susan B Cowles all of Greene.
REYNOLDS - RADEY: In Oxford [Chenango Co. NY] May 10th by Rev. William R. Baldwin, Mr. Job H. Reynolds of Detroit, Mich., to Miss Margaret Radey of South New Berlin, N.Y. [Chenango Co. NY]
BRIGGS - CLEVELAND: A pleasant party assembled at the house of Elmer Isbell in Sherburne [Chenango Co. NY] last Wednesday evening, the occasion being the marriage of Will P. Briggs to Miss Minnie E Cleveland both of this village [Smyrna, Chenango Co. NY]. The officiating clergyman was Rev. J.L. Race, the recent pastor of the M.E. Church, who, with his usual hilarity added much to the pleasure of the occasion. The ceremony was performed at 9 P.M. and after congratulations, etc., the party repaired to the dining room and partook of a supper fit for a royal family. The bride and groom were the recipients of a large number of valuable gifts and when at a late hour, the company left for their homes, all felt that it had been one of the most pleasant events of a lifetime. William has many friends in this community who wish him and his newly wedded wife a long life and a bright one, with never a cloud nor a shadow to darken it.
GRANT - SMITH: In Auburn [Cayuga Co. NY], April 30th, by Rev. L.L. Briggs, Mr. W.W. Grant of Cincinnatus [Cortland Co. NY] to Miss Philona Smith of Auburn.
BISSELL: A large number of the friends of Mr. and Mrs. H.F. Bissell made them a surprise visit on Monday evening, it being the fifteenth anniversary of their marriage. The occasion was one of extreme pleasure to all who participated and the visit extended into the small hours of the night. We extend our congratulations to the worthy couple and hope that we may be present on the occasion of their golden anniversary.
Deaths
GREENMAN: In this village [Norwich, Chenango Co. NY] on Tuesday morning, May 13th, Mr. Benjamin F. Greenman aged 55 years. Funeral services will be held at his late residence on Friday afternoon at four o'clock.
SMITH: In Norwich [Chenango Co. NY] May 12th, Mrs. Sallie N. Smith wife of Erasmus Smith, aged 74 years.
CHILD: In Plymouth [Chenango Co. NY] suddenly, May 6th, Mr. Joseph Uri Child aged 67 years.
HOYT: In Coventry, N.Y. [Chenango Co.] on Sunday, May 11th, 1879, in the 85th year of her age, Mrs. Hannah Hoyt widow of the late Thaddeus Hoyt. She had been feeble in health for a long time but at last dropped away very suddenly and peacefully and entered into rest.
ALLEN: In Otselic [Chenango Co. NY] April 30th, of heart disease, Mr. A.F. Allen aged 72 years, late of Greene [Chenango Co. NY].
HARRINGTON: In Greene [Chenango Co. NY] April 20th, of diphtheria, Nellie M. [Harrington] aged 11 months and 20 days; April 24th, Sidney D. [Harrington] aged 2 years, 9 months and 8 days; April 27th, Vernie L. [Harrington] aged 7 years 8 months and 3 days, children of Charles and Hattie Harrington.
SMITH: In Afton [Chenango Co. NY] May 4th, Julia M. [Smith] wife of Samuel Smith, aged 50 years.
WIDGER: In Browning, Iowa, Mr. Ralph D. Widger aged 33 years, formerly of Oxford [Chenango Co. NY]
News Item
Belfield Murder Trial
The trial of Isaiah Belfield for the murder of Mrs. Phebe Crandall in Brookfield, Madison county [NY] in 1865, is now going on in Morrisville [Madison Co. NY] and much interest in manifested.
Henry D. Crandall, aged seventy-nine years, husband of the murdered woman is the principal witness and swears positively that Belfield is one of the two men who entered his house on the night of December 7th, 1865, demanded his money and bonds and attacked him upon his refusal to get them; that in the melee he threw Belfield to the floor, where he held him for some minutes, looking him full in the face; that a general fight ensued in which pistols were used by the ruffians, the old gentleman defending himself with sticks of stove wood. In his account of the struggle for life he says: "We now was engaged, all three of us, in all manner of shapes in which ever man was in; first I had them down and then they had me down. This man (pointing to Belfield) drew a pistol and shot me in the head, back of the ear, there" (indicated with his thumb). They then overpowered him, and he intimated that he would give them his money. Belfield said "Go," and he went toward his bedroom, where he kept his money in the bed. He went through the passage, not for the purpose of getting his money, but to get a cudgel, his "headache stick," as he called it (a flail swing). He struck at the robbers, but the stick was too long and hit the casing. The door was partially opened and a hand was thrust in firing a pistol, the ball lodging in the wall. A hand was thrust in the second time, but he struck it. The robbers then opened the door and a struggle ensued, when Crandall became suddenly unconscious. When he regained consciousness, the old man found his wife dead, and then he gave the alarm. His wife had $25 in a pocketbook, which he never saw after that night. He had over $500 in money and $2600 in bonds, which he kept in the straw tick in the bed. None of these were taken.
The testimony of Nellie Smith who lived with the notorious Loomises in the neighborhood for sixteen years and was Grove's mistress, was an important witness for the people, as Belfield was a frequent visitor at the Loomis mansion, and she testified to his movements, with others, on the day of the murder and the day after. Belfield visited the house on the night after the murder in company with Jack Curtiss and Joe Crandall (nephew of the murdered woman) who are supposed to have been his partners in the crime and while they were in the front room, in company with Cornelia Loomis, Nellie overheard a conversation between them, which she was not allowed to testify to, and which had been relied upon by the prosecution as of importance. This conversation, as stated by the District Attorney in his opening, was to the effect that Cornelia said they had done a bad thing to kill two persons for so little money. One of the men replied that they were obliged to do it, because they fought so hard. To this Cornelia answered that if she had killed two persons she would have obtained more money. Nellie's story of the Loomis house and its workings was listened to with rapt attention by the great crowd in the Court room. she described the fight when Wash was killed, and Grove badly wounded and when deputy sheriff Filkins was shot and Eph. Conger hurt. She is sole legatee of Grove's estate and there is the feeling over the disprotioning of the same.
Other witnesses, residing in the neighborhood at the time, have been sworn, and the trial will probably continue through the week.
Chenango Union, Norwich NY, May 22, 1879: Belfield, whose trial for the murder of Mrs. Phebe Crandall in Brookfield in 1865 has occupied the Court at Morrisville during the past two weeks, was acquitted, the jury bringing in a verdict of "not guilty" on Saturday evening. The question of the identity of the prisoner is said to have controlled the verdict and the failure of the prosecution to prove that Belfield's hair was colored turned it in his favor. Immediately upon his discharge by the Court, he was again made prisoner and returned to jail, under the indictment charging him with assault with intend to kill Henry D. Crandall. The prisoner feels jubilant and has no fear of conviction under this indictment. The District Attorney, it is understood, will not move the trial until the December term.